Page images
PDF
EPUB

of the safety valves, (as they were probably fast,) a terrific explosion of the weakest boiler took place, which tore up the plates along the bottom, and, the steam having no outlet at the top, not only burst out the end next the furnace, demolishing the building in that direction, but, tearing up the top on the opposite side, the boiler was projected upwards in an oblique direction, carrying the floors, walls, and every other obstruction before it; ultimately it lodged itself across the railway at some distance from the building. Looking at the disastrous consequences of this accident, and the number of persons (from 16 to 18) who lost their lives on the occasion, it became a subject of deep interest to the community that a close investigation should immediately be instituted, and a recommendation followed that every precaution should be used in the construction as well as the management of boilers.

The next fatal occurrence on record in this district was a boiler at Ashtonunder-Lyne, which exploded under similar circumstances, namely, from excessive interior pressure, when four or five lives were lost; and again at Hyde, where a similar accident occurred from the same cause, which was afterwards traced to the insane act of the stoker or engineer, who prevented all means for the steam to escape by tying down the safety valve.

There was a boiler explosion at Malaga, in Spain, some years since, and my reason for noticing it in this place is to show that explosions may be apprehended from other causes than those enumerated in the divisions of this inquiry, and one of these is incrustation. Dr. Ritterbrandt says, in a paper read before the Institution of Civil Engineers, by an eminent chemist, Mr. West—“That a sudden evolution of steam under circumstances of incrustation is no uncommon occurrence. In several instances I have known this to be the case, particularly in marine boilers, where the incrustation from salt water becomes a serious grievance, either as regards the duration of the boiler, or the economy of fuel.

If it were supposed, as Dr. Ritterbrandt observes, that the boiler was incrusted to the extent of half an inch, it would at once be seen that nothing was more easy than to heat the boiler strongly, even to a red heat, without the immediate contact of water. Under these circumstances, the hardened deposits being firmly attached to the plates, and forming an imperfect conductor of heat, would tend greatly to increase the temperature of the iron, and the difference of temperature thus induced between the iron and the incrustation, and the greater expansibility of the iron, would cause the incrustation to separate from the plates, and the water rushing in between them, would generate a considerable charge of highly elastic steam, and thus endanger the security of the boiler.

These phenomena were singularly exemplified in the Malaga explosion, which is thus described by Mr. Hick:-" I have ascertained that a very thick incrustation of salt was formed on the lower part of the boiler, immediately over the fire, and so far as it extended the plates appear to have been red hot, being thereby much weakened, and hence the explosion. The ordinary working pressure of the boiler is 130 lbs. per square inch, and perhaps at the time of the explosion very much above that pressure, as there was only one small safety valve of two and a-half inches diameter. The boiler was only two feet six inches diameter, and twenty feet long."

Incrustation, exclusive of being dangerous, is attended with great expense and injury to the boiler by its removal. In the case of the transatlantic, oriental, or other long sea-going vessels, even after the use of brine-pumps, blowing out, &c., a very large amount of incrustation is formed, and considerable sums of money are expended each voyage to remove it.

Other explosions of a more recent date are those which occurred at Bradford

and Halifax. They are still fresh in the recollection of the public mind, and are so well known as not to require notice in this place.

I cannot, however, leave this part of the subject without reverting to an accident which occurred on the Lancashire and Yorkshire Railway, which had its origin in the same cause-excessive internal pressure. This accident is the more peculiar as it led to a long mathematical disquisition as to the nature of the forces which produced results at once curious and interesting. The conclusions which I arrived at, although practically right, were, however, considered by some mathematically wrong, as they were firmly combatted by several eminent mathematicians; but notwithstanding the number of algebraic formulas, and the learned discussions of my friends on that occasion, I have been unable to change the opinions I then formed, for others more conclusive.

The accident here alluded to occurred to the " Irk" locomotive engine, which, in February, 1845, blew up and killed the driver, stoker, and another person who was standing near the spot at the time. A great difference of opinion as to the cause of this accident was prevalent in the minds of those who witnessed the explosion, some attributing it to a crack in the copper fire box, and others to the weakness of the stays over the top. Neither of these opinions was, however, correct, as it was afterwards demonstrated that the material was not only entirely free from cracks and flaws, but the stays were proved sufficient to resist a pressure of 150 to 200 lbs. on the square inch. The true cause was afterwards ascertained to arise from the fastening down of the safety valve of the engine, (an active fire being in operation under the boiler at the time), which was under the shed, with the steam up, ready to start with the early morning train. The effect of this was the forcing down of the top of the copper fire-box upon the blazing embers of the furnace, which, acting upon the principle of the rocket, elevated the boiler and engine of 20 tons weight to a height of 30 feet, which, in its ascent, made a summerset in the air, passed through the roof of the shed, and ultimately landed at a distance of 60 yards from its original position. The question which excited most interest, was the absolute force required to fracture the fire-box, its peculiar properties when once liberated, and the elastic or continuous powers in operation, which forced the engine from its place to an elevation of 30 feet from the position in which it stood. An elaborate mathematical discussion ensued relative to the nature of these forces, which ended in the opinion that a pressure sufficient to rupture the fire-box, was, by its continuous action, sufficient to elevate the boiler and produce the results which followed. Another reason was assigned, namely, that an accumulated force of elastic vapour, at a high temperature, with no outlet through the valves, having suddenly burst upon the glowing embers of the furnace, would charge the products of combustion with their equivalents of oxygen, and hence explosion followed. Whether one or both of these two causes were in operation is probably difficult to determine; at all events, we have in many instances precisely the same results produced from similar causes, and unless greater precaution is used in the prevention of excessive pressure, we may naturally expect a repetition of the same fatal consequences.

The preventives against accidents of this kind are, well constructed boilers of the strongest form, and duly proportioned safety valves; one under the immediate control of the engineer, and the other, as a reserve, under the keeping of some competent authority.

2nd. Explosions from deficiency of water.

This division of the subject requires the utmost care and attention, as the circumstance of boilers being short of water is no unusual occurrence. Im

B

minent danger frequently arises from this cause; and it cannot be too forcibly impressed upon the minds of engineers, that there is no part of the apparatus constituting the mountings of a boiler which require greater attention-probably the safety valves not excepted-than that which supplies it with water. A well constructed pump, and self-acting feeders, when boilers are worked at a low pressure, are indispensable; and where the latter cannot be applied, the glass tubular gauge, steam, and water cocks must have more than ordinary attention.

In a properly constructed boiler every part of the metal exposed to the direct action of the fire should be in immediate contact with the water, and when proper provision is made to maintain the water at a sufficient height above the part of the plates so exposed, accidents can never occur from this cause.

We

Should the water, however, get low from defects in the pump, or any stoppage of the regulating feed valves, and the plates over the furnace become red hot, we then risk the bursting of the boiler, even at the ordinary working pressure. have no occasion, under such circumstances, to search for another cause, from the fact that the material when raised to a red heat has lost about five-sixths of its strength, and a force of less than one-sixth will be found amply sufficient to bear down the plates direct upon the fire, or to burst the boiler.

When a boiler becomes short of water, the first, and perhaps the most natural action, is to run to the feed valve, and pull it wide open. This certainly remedies the deficiency, but increases the danger, by suddenly pouring upon the incandescent plates a large body of water, which, coming in contact with a reservoir of intense heat, is calculated to produce highly elastic steam. This has been hitherto controverted by several eminent chemists and philosophers; but I make no doubt such is the case, unless the pressure has forced the plates into a concave shape, which for a time would retard the evaporization of the water when suddenly thrown upon them. Some curious experimental facts have been elicited on this subject, and those of M. Boutigny, and Professor Bowman, of King's College, London, show that a small quantity of water projected upon a hot plate does not touch it; that it forms itself into a globule surrounded with a thin film, and rolls about upon the plate without the least appearance of evaporation. A repulsive action takes place, and these phenomena are explained upon the supposition that the spheroid has a perfectly reflecting surface, and consequently the heat of the incandescent plate is reflected back upon it. What is, however, the most extraordinary in these experiments, is the fact that the globule, whilst rolling upon a red hot plate, never exceeds a temperature of about 204° of Fahrenheit; and in order to produce ebullition, it is necessary to cool the plate until the water begins to boil, when it is rapidly dissipated in steam. The experiments by the committee of the Franklin Institute on this subject, give some interesting and useful results. That committee found that the temperature at which clean iron vaporized drops of water, was 334° Fahrenheit. The development of a repulsive force which I have endeavoured to describe was, however, so rapid above that temperature, that drops which required but one second of time to disappear at the temperature of maximum vaporization, required 152 seconds when the metal was heated to 395° of Fahrenheit. The committee go on to state that" One ounce of water introduced into an iron bowl three-sixteenths of an inch thick, and supplied with heat by an oil-bath, at the temperature of 546°, was vaporized in fifteen seconds, while at the initial temperature of 507°, that of the most rapid evaporization was thirteen seconds." The cooling effect of the metal is here strikingly exemplified by the increased rapidity of the evaporization, which at a reduced temperature of 38° is effected in thirteen instead of fifteen seconds.

This does not, however, hold good in every case, as an increased quantity of water, say from one-eighth of an ounce to two ounces, thrown upon heated plates, raised the temperature of vaporization from 460° to 600° Fahrenheit: thus clearly showing that the time required for the generation of explosive steam under these circumstances is attended with danger; and it may be doubted whether the ordinary safety valves may not be wholly inadequate for its

escape.

Numerous examples may be quoted to show that explosions from deficiency of water, although less frequent than those arising from undue pressure, are by no means uncommon. They are nevertheless comparatively fewer in number, and the preventives are good pumps, self-acting feeders, (when they can be applied), and all those conveniences, such as water cocks, water gauges, floats, alarms, and other indicators of the loss and reduction of water in the boiler.

3rd. Explosions produced from collapse.

Accidents from this cause can scarcely be called explosions, as they arise, not from internal force which bursts the boiler, but from the sudden action of a vacuum within it. In high pressure boilers, from their superior strength and circular form, these accidents seldom occur, and the low pressure boiler is effectually guarded against it by a valve which opens inwards by the pressure of the atmosphere whenever a vacuum occurs. In some cases a collapse of the internal flues of boilers has been known to take place, from a partial vacuum within, which, united to the pressure of the steam, has forced down the top and sides of the flue, and with fatal effect discharged the contents of the boiler into the ash-pit, and destroyed and scalded everything before it. A circumstance of this kind occurred on the Thames on board the steamer Victoria, some years since, when a number of persons lost their lives, and serious injury was sustained in all parts of the vessel within reach of the steam. This accident could not, however, be called an explosion, but a collapse of the internal flues, which were of large dimensions, and the consequent discharge of large quantities of steam and water into the space occupied by the engines.

One or two cases which bear more directly on this point are, however, on record, and one of them, which took place in the Mold mines, in Flintshire, was attended with explosion. The particulars, as given by Mr. John Taylor, will be found circumstantially recorded in the first volume of the Philosophical Magazine. This occurrence seems to prove that rarefaction produced in the flues of a high pressure boiler may determine an explosion. The boiler which exploded belonged to a set of three feeding the same engine; the fuel used was bituminous coal. The furnace doors of all three of the boilers had been opened, and the dampers of two had been closed, when a gust of flame was seen to issue from the mouth of the furnace of these latter, and was immediately followed by an explosion. The interior flue of this boiler was flattened from the sides, the flue and shell of the boiler remaining in their places, and the safety valve upon the latter not being injured.

Other similar cases of collapse might be stated, but as most of them have been attended by a defective supply of water in the boiler, the plates over the fire having become heated, they can scarcely be included in the category of this class of accidents, and more properly belong to those of which we have just treated,— explosions from a deficiency of water in the boiler.

It is, nevertheless, necessary to observe, that cases of collapse should be carefully guarded against, as the great source of danger is in the escape of hot water, which, with the steam generated by it, produces death in one of its worst and most painful forms.

The remedies for these accidents will be found in the vacuum valve, and careful construction in the form and strength of the flues.

4th. Explosions from defective construction.

This is, perhaps, one of the most important divisions that can possibly engage our attention, and on which it shall be my duty to enlarge. In a previous inquiry, I have already shown the nature of the strain and the ultimate resistance which the material used in the construction of boilers is able to bear. We have not, however, in all cases, shown the distribution and position in which that material should be placed in order to attain the maximum of strength, and afford to the public greater security in the resisting powers of vessels subject to severe and sometimes ruinous pressure. This is a subject of such importance that I shall be under the necessity of trespassing upon your time, in endeavouring to point out the advantages peculiar to form, and the use of a sound and perfect system of construction.

For a number of years the haycock, hemispherical, and waggon-shaped boilers were those generally in use; and it was not until high pressure steam was first introduced into Cornwall, that the cylindrical form with hemispherical ends, and the furnace under the boiler, came into use. Subsequently this gave way to the introduction of a large internal flue extending the whole length of the boiler, and in this the furnace was placed. For many years this was the best and most economical boiler in Cornwall, and its introduction into this country has effected great improvements in the economy of fuel as well as the strength of the boiler. Several attempts have been made to improve this boiler by cutting away one-half of the end, in order to admit a larger furnace. This was first done by the Butterley Company, and it has since gone by the name of the Butterley boiler. This con

[graphic][subsumed][merged small]

struction has the same defects as the haycock or hemispherical and waggon-shaped boilers; it is weak over the fire place, and cannot well be strengthened without injury to the part A, Fig. 1, of the boiler, from the vast number of stays necessary to suspend the part which forms the canopy of the furnace. Of late years a much greater improvement has, however, been effected by the double flue, в в Fig. 2,

[graphic][subsumed][subsumed][merged small]
« PreviousContinue »